facebook
Traded Co logo
Submit
Daily limit: 0/10

Schrute Properties LLC Acquires 42-Unit Multifamily Building From William Paladino For $5.2M

Property Image
SOLD
$5,200,000

New York

See Similar Deals
MultiFamily
Sold 09/19/2025
the dealplayerscompscontact
Property Image
SOLD

Schrute Properties LLC Acquires 42-Unit Multifamily Building From William Paladino For $5.2M

24 South Johnson Park

See Similar Deals
MultiFamily
Sold 09/19/2025
Contact now

Summary

NEW YORK
Asset Type:MultiFamily
Transaction Type:Sale

The transaction involved a multifamily asset located at 24 South Johnson Park in Buffalo. The property, known as The Graystone, consists of 42 units and was sold for $5,200,000, resulting in a price per unit of $123,810. Originally constructed as a hotel in 1897, the building underwent renovations in 2014 to convert it into apartments.

Summary of transaction details:

  • Property Type: Multifamily
  • Transaction Amount: $5,200,000
  • Units: 42
  • Price Per Unit: $123,810
  • Buyer: Schrute Properties LLC
  • Seller: William Paladino - Ellicott Development
  • Broker: Robert Stewart - Pyramid Brokerage Company
  • Date of Transaction: 09/19/2025

William Paladino, representing Ellicott Development, completed the sale of the historic apartment building to Schrute Properties LLC. Robert Stewart served as the broker for this transaction, facilitating the deal in the Buffalo market and contributing to a growing trend of multifamily acquisitions in the region.

Players

Robert Stewart
2 deals$87.6M volume(716) 868-1875
BROKER

Pyramid Brokerage Company
BROKERAGE

William Paladino
Ellicott Development
1 deal$5.2M volume
SELLER

Details

SOLD
IMAGE: William Paladino & Robert Stewart DATE: 09/19/2025 ADDRESS: 24 South Johnson Park MARKET: Buffalo ASSET TYPE: Multifamily BUYER: Schrute Properties LLC SELLER: William Paladino - Ellicott Development (@Ellicott.Development) BROKER: Robert Stewart - Pyramid Brokerage Company SALE PRICE: $5,200,000 UNITS: 42 ~ PPU: $123,810 NOTE: Ellicott Development sold The Graystone, a 42-unit historic apartment building in Downtown Buffalo, to Schrute Properties for $5.2M. The building, originally a 1897 hotel, was renovated into apartments in 2014, and the new owners continue a local multifamily buying streak.

Stay in the Know

Subscribe for insider commercial real estate news, deal highlights, and market insights—delivered straight to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Similar Deals

Contact

Get in touch with the broker you want

Suggestions
CRE CalculatorAnalyze deals based on income, expenses, and financing. We automatically filled the calculator with data from the deal you are viewing, fill free to modify it to see how it affects the results.
Deal Type
Operating Income
Operating Expenses (Annual)
Net Operating Income (NOI)

$277,333.32

Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR)

0.94x

Cap Rate

5.33%

Cash Flow (Annual)-$18,474.52
Cash-on-Cash Return-1.27%
Monthly Debt Service$24,650.65
Annual Debt Service$295,807.83