facebook
TradedTraded
    Home
    Search
    Closings
    Listings
    On Market
    Off Market
    Add a listing
    Vaults
    shh
    Rankings
    News
    Data
    Socials
    More


Messages

Go Pro
+ Submit+ Submit a Deal
Home

/

Deals

/

New York

/

Mixed Use

/

Sale

/

2204 Fulton Street

Updated Jan 22, 2026

Bilt advertisement
Jorge Benavides Acquires Mixed-Use Property In Brooklyn From Ari Schwartz For $1.325M
SOLDMixed-use

Jorge Benavides Acquires Mixed-Use Property In Brooklyn From Ari Schwartz For $1.325M

2204 Fulton Street

$1,325,000

$283/SF

Building Size

4,680 SF

Asset Type

Mixed-use

Closing

Dec 3, 2025

About this deal

AI

The asset involved in this transaction is a mixed-use property located at 2204 Fulton Street, Brooklyn. It comprises four residential units and one commercial space, covering a total of 4,680 square feet. The sale price was $1,325,000, resulting in a price per unit of $265,000 and a price per square foot of $283.

Summary of transaction details:

  • Property Type: Mixed-use (4 Residential & 1 Commercial)
  • Transaction Amount: $1,325,000
  • Buyer: Jorge Benavides
  • Seller: Ari Schwartz
  • Brokers: DJ Johnston & Evan Kashanian - Matthews
  • Units: 5
  • Square Footage: 4,680
  • Price per Unit: $265,000
  • Price per Square Foot: $283

Matthews™ represented the lender/owner in the sale, which was characterized as an REO transaction for a fully vacant four-family property in shell condition. Following a rigorous marketing campaign, multiple qualified buyers were identified, ultimately leading to Jorge Benavides successfully closing the deal. Despite a prior basement fire that left the property requiring a full renovation, the buyer perceived it as an opportunity to renovate and reposition the asset.

Players

DJ Johnston

Matthews

Broker

$504.3M

vol

105 deals

Broker
Matthews
Matthews Brokerage
Ari Schwartzbard

Ari Schwartzbard

Seller

$5.8B

vol

22 deals

Seller

Brooklyn Mixed-use Market Snapshot

Boundary boundary · Mixed-use · Sale transactions

Loading comparables…

Deal FAQ

About $283 per square foot on a published $1.3M for 4,680 square feet (2025).

Visit Ari Schwartzbard to view all their deals.

Browse Brooklyn mixed use sales on Traded.

Purchase Price

Annual NOI

Loan Amount

Interest Rate (%)

Loan Term (yrs)

Down Payment (%)

Cap Rate

11.97%

Cash-on-Cash

-3.42%

Monthly Payment

$14,164

Annual Debt Svc

$169,964

Annual Cash Flow

$-11,334

DSCR

0.93

More Deals

Nearby Markets