Updated Sep 2, 2026
Joy Behar Sells Sag Harbor Home At 98 Bay Street For $5.65M With Brokers Ed Gaetjens & John Wines
98 Bay Street
$5,650,000
$1,255/SF
Building Size
4,500 SF
Asset Type
Single Family
Closing
Sep 2, 2026
About this deal
AI
A single-family home located at 98 Bay Street in Sag Harbor has been sold for $5.65 million. The property spans 4,500 square feet, which equates to a price per square foot of $1,256. The sale was completed on September 2, 2026.
Summary of transaction details:
- Property Type: Single Family
- Transaction Amount: $5,650,000
- Address: 98 Bay Street
- Market: Sag Harbor
- Square Footage: 4,500
- Price Per Square Foot: $1,256
- Seller: Joy Behar
- Brokers: Ed Gaetjens & John Wines - Saunders & Associates
Joy Behar sold the property, which was initially listed at $11 million in late 2024, indicating a significant drop in the sale price from her original asking price.
Players
Sag Harbor Single Family Market Snapshot
Boundary boundary · Single Family · Sale transactions
Loading comparables…
Deal FAQ
About $1.3K per square foot on a published $5.7M for 4,500 square feet (2026).
Visit Saunders & Associates to view all their deals.
Browse Sag Harbor single family sales on Traded.
Purchase Price
Annual NOI
Loan Amount
Interest Rate (%)
Loan Term (yrs)
Down Payment (%)
Cap Rate
2.81%
Cash-on-Cash
-0.80%
Monthly Payment
$14,164
Annual Debt Svc
$169,964
Annual Cash Flow
$-11,334
DSCR
0.93