Barbara Corcoran Sells Carnegie Hill Co-Op For $13.5 Million With Brokers Scott Stewart Carrie Chiang And Andres Perea-Garzon
1158 5th Avenue
$13,500,000
$2,934/SF
Building Size
4,600 SF
Asset Type
Co-Op
Closing
Oct 25, 2025
AI
A co-op located at 1158 5th Avenue in Carnegie Hill was sold for $13,500,000. The property spans 4,600 square feet, equating to a price per square foot of $2,935. The seller, Barbara Corcoran, previously acquired the penthouse for $10 million in 2015 and invested $2 million in renovations.
Summary of transaction details:
- Property Type: Co-Op
- Transaction Amount: $13,500,000
- Square Footage: 4,600
- Price per Square Foot: $2,935
- Address: 1158 5th Avenue
- Market: Carnegie Hill
- Seller: Barbara Corcoran
- Brokers: Scott Stewart, Carrie Chiang & Andres Perea-Garzon - The Corcoran Group
The transaction was notable for occurring less than a day after listing. A bidding war ensued, leading to the sale being $1.5 million over asking price as Corcoran and her husband decided to relocate uptown to a more accessible condo.
Players
New York Co-Op Market Snapshot
Boundary boundary · Co-Op · Sale transactions
Loading comparables…
Purchase Price
Annual NOI
Loan Amount
Interest Rate (%)
Loan Term (yrs)
Down Payment (%)
Cap Rate
1.18%
Cash-on-Cash
-0.34%
Monthly Payment
$14,164
Annual Debt Svc
$169,964
Annual Cash Flow
$-11,334
DSCR
0.93