facebook


Go Pro
+ Submit+ Submit a Deal
Home

/

Deals

/

New Jersey

/

Retail

/

Sale

/

134 Water Street

Updated Sep 29, 2026

Marcus & Millichap Facilitates $7.12M Sale Of Two Mavis Discount Tire Properties In NJ
SOLDRetail

Marcus & Millichap Facilitates $7.12M Sale Of Two Mavis Discount Tire Properties In NJ

134 Water Street, 74 Westfield Ave. In Roselle Park & 74 Westfield Avenue West

$7,120,000

$332/SF

Building Size

21,412 SF

Asset Type

Retail

Closing

Sep 28, 2026

About this deal

AI

Two retail properties located at 134 Water Street and 74 Westfield Avenue in Newton and Roselle Park, NJ respectively, were involved in a closed sale. The combined sale price for these properties was $7,120,000, with the Newton property measuring 11,412 square feet and the Roselle Park property measuring 10,000 square feet. The price per square foot for the total transaction was $333.

Summary of transaction details:

  • Property Type: Retail
  • Transaction Amount: $7,120,000
  • Newton Property Address: 134 Water Street
  • Newton Property Sale Price: $3,570,000
  • Newton Property Square Footage: 11,412
  • Roselle Park Property Address: 74 Westfield Avenue
  • Roselle Park Property Sale Price: $3,550,000
  • Roselle Park Property Square Footage: 10,000
  • Market: Newton & Roselle Park, NJ
  • Brokers: Alan Cafiero, David Cafiero, John Moroz & Damien Rance - Marcus & Millichap

Marcus & Millichap brokers Alan Cafiero, David Cafiero, John Moroz, and Damien Rance represented the sellers and procured the buyers for both transactions. They noted an increase in demand for net-leased automotive properties featuring established tenants in well-located areas.

On the Map

Open live map

$7,120,000

$332/SF

Retail

View full map

Players

Alan Cafiero

Marcus & Millichap

Broker

$845.6M

vol

114 deals

Broker

Tekoa Retail Market Snapshot

Boundary boundary · Retail · Sale transactions

Loading comparables…

Deal FAQ

About $332 per square foot on a published $7.1M for 21,412 square feet (2026).

Visit John Moroz to view all their deals.

Browse Tekoa retail sales on Traded.

Purchase Price

Annual NOI

Loan Amount

Interest Rate (%)

Loan Term (yrs)

Down Payment (%)

Cap Rate

2.23%

Cash-on-Cash

-0.64%

Monthly Payment

$14,164

Annual Debt Svc

$169,964

Annual Cash Flow

$-11,334

DSCR

0.93

More Deals

Nearby Markets