facebook
TradedTraded
    Home
    Search
    Closings
    Listings
    On Market
    Off Market
    Add a listing
    Vaults
    shh
    Rankings
    News
    Data
    Socials
    More


Messages

Go Pro
+ Submit+ Submit a Deal
Home

/

Deals

/

New Jersey

/

Retail

/

Sale

/

280 Route 37 East

Marcus & Millichap Sells Mavis Discount Tire Property In Toms River For $3.49M
SOLDRetail

Marcus & Millichap Sells Mavis Discount Tire Property In Toms River For $3.49M

280 Route 37 East

$3,490,000

$509/SF

Building Size

6,853 SF

Asset Type

Retail

Closing

Jun 24, 2025

AI

The asset involved in the transaction is a retail property located at 280 Route 37 in Toms River, NJ. The property spans 1.22 acres and has a total square footage of 6,853. It was sold for $3,490,000, with a price per square foot of $509. The asset is under a corporate-guaranteed net lease through 2030 and has been fully leased, attracting significant investor interest amidst a trend of rising demand for net-leased retail properties.

Summary of transaction details:

  • Property Type: Retail
  • Transaction Amount: $3,490,000
  • Asset Size: 6,853 SF
  • Price Per SF: $509
  • Address: 280 Route 37, Toms River, NJ
  • Market: Toms River
  • Acres: 1.22

The transaction was facilitated by brokers Alan Cafiero, Brent Hyldahl, and Seth Goldberg from Marcus & Millichap, who arranged the sale of the fully leased Mavis Discount Tire property, capitalizing on a broader uptick in 1031 exchange activity and investor interest in the retail segment.

Players

Brent Hyldahl

Marcus & Millichap

Broker

$436.2M

vol

57 deals

Broker
Marcus & Millichap
Marcus & MillichapBrokerage

Toms River Retail Market Snapshot

Boundary boundary · Retail · Sale transactions

Loading comparables…

Purchase Price

Annual NOI

Loan Amount

Interest Rate (%)

Loan Term (yrs)

Down Payment (%)

Cap Rate

4.55%

Cash-on-Cash

-1.30%

Monthly Payment

$14,164

Annual Debt Svc

$169,964

Annual Cash Flow

$-11,334

DSCR

0.93