Marc Fisher Sells Waterfront Edgartown Estate For $37.5 Million With Gerret Conover As The Broker

The property asset involved in the transaction is a single-family home located at 48 Witchwood Lane in Edgartown, MA. This waterfront estate, designed with a Gatsby-inspired theme, spans 15,000 square feet and includes seven bedrooms, a bowling alley, a pool, and a dock, all set on three acres of waterfront land. The property sold for $37,500,000, translating to a price per square foot of $2,500.

Summary of transaction details:

• Property Type: Single Family
• Transaction Amount: $37,500,000
• Address: 48 Witchwood Lane
• Market: Edgartown, MA
• Square Footage: 15,000
• Price Per Square Foot: $2,500
• Broker: Gerret Conover - LandVest

The sale was finalized on 11/05/2025, setting a new record for Martha’s Vineyard, exceeding the previous record held by President Obama’s former summer home, which sold for $37 million. The previous owners of the estate were shoe designer Marc Fisher and his wife, who acquired the property in 2015.