facebook
Traded Co logo
Submit
Daily limit: 0/10

Marc Fisher Sells Waterfront Edgartown Estate For $37.5 Million With Gerret Conover As The Broker

Property Image
SOLD
$37,500,000

Massachusetts

See Similar Deals
Single Family15,000 SF
Sold 11/05/2025
the dealplayerscompscontact
Property Image
SOLD

Marc Fisher Sells Waterfront Edgartown Estate For $37.5 Million With Gerret Conover As The Broker

48 Witchwood Lane

See Similar Deals
Single Family15,000 SF
Sold 11/05/2025
Contact now

Summary

MASSACHUSETTS
Asset Type:Single Family
Price Per Square Foot:$2,500
Total Square Footage:15,000 SF
Transaction Type:Sale

The property asset involved in the transaction is a single-family home located at 48 Witchwood Lane in Edgartown, MA. This waterfront estate, designed with a Gatsby-inspired theme, spans 15,000 square feet and includes seven bedrooms, a bowling alley, a pool, and a dock, all set on three acres of waterfront land. The property sold for $37,500,000, translating to a price per square foot of $2,500.

Summary of transaction details:

  • Property Type: Single Family
  • Transaction Amount: $37,500,000
  • Address: 48 Witchwood Lane
  • Market: Edgartown, MA
  • Square Footage: 15,000
  • Price Per Square Foot: $2,500
  • Broker: Gerret Conover - LandVest

The sale was finalized on 11/05/2025, setting a new record for Martha’s Vineyard, exceeding the previous record held by President Obama’s former summer home, which sold for $37 million. The previous owners of the estate were shoe designer Marc Fisher and his wife, who acquired the property in 2015.

Players

GC
4 deals$66.1M volume
BROKER

BROKERAGE

Details

SOLD
IMAGE: Marc Fisher, The Gatsby & Gerret Conover DATE: 11/05/2025 ADDRESS: 48 Witchwood Lane MARKET: Edgartown, MA ASSET TYPE: Single Family BROKER: Gerret Conover - LandVest SALE PRICE: $37,500,000 SF: 15,000 ~ PPSF: $2,500 NOTE: A waterfront Edgartown estate on Martha’s Vineyard sold for $37.5 million, setting a new record for the island and surpassing President Obama’s former summer home, which sold for $37 million. The Gatsby-inspired 15,000-square-foot property, owned by shoe designer Marc Fisher and his wife since 2015, features seven bedrooms, a bowling alley, pool, dock, and three acres of waterfront.

Stay in the Know

Subscribe for insider commercial real estate news, deal highlights, and market insights—delivered straight to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Similar Deals

Contact

Get in touch with the broker you want

Suggestions
CRE CalculatorAnalyze deals based on income, expenses, and financing. We automatically filled the calculator with data from the deal you are viewing, fill free to modify it to see how it affects the results.
Deal Type
Operating Income
Operating Expenses (Annual)
Net Operating Income (NOI)

$1,999,999.99

Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR)

0.94x

Cap Rate

5.33%

Cash Flow (Annual)-$133,229.59
Cash-on-Cash Return-1.27%
Monthly Debt Service$177,769.13
Annual Debt Service$2,133,229.58