facebook


Go ProSubmit a deal
Submit
Multifamily

Nov 18, 2026

NYC Landlords Could Save Hundreds of Millions With a Minor State Rule Change

New York's DHCR updated Fact Sheet 40 in November 2026 to clarify that temporary rent concessions are legally distinct from preferential rents, aiding landlords in defending against overcharge.

NYC Landlords Could Save Hundreds of Millions With a Minor State Rule Change
Traded Media
Traded Media

Traded Editorial

3 min read
  • New York’s DHCR updated Fact Sheet 40 in November 2026, clarifying that temporary rent concessions can be legally distinct from preferential rents.
  • The change could help landlords defend against a wave of rent-overcharge lawsuits involving more than 24 properties and 12,000 apartments.
  • The clarification does not automatically dismiss existing cases. Courts will still examine the circumstances and terms of individual rent concession agreements.

What DHCR Changed in Its Rent Regulation Guidance

New York City landlords received a potentially significant regulatory reprieve after the state Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR) revised its guidance on preferential rents and rent concessions.

The updated Fact Sheet 40 restores an important distinction between the two arrangements. A preferential rent is a recurring monthly rent below the legal regulated rent, while a rent concession can provide temporary relief, such as several rent-free months, without necessarily changing the apartment's underlying legal rent.

The distinction matters because the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 (HSTPA) requires landlords to continue charging preferential rents to rent-stabilized tenants for as long as they remain in the apartment, subject to permitted increases.

What Triggered the Wave of Landlord Lawsuits

The controversy began after DHCR removed language distinguishing concessions from preferential rents when it revised Fact Sheet 40 following the 2019 law.

Landlord attorneys argued that the removal created confusion and was interpreted by courts as a change in agency policy. That interpretation helped fuel litigation claiming that temporary rent concessions should be treated as preferential rents, potentially requiring landlords to calculate renewal increases from the lower amount.

The issue gained momentum following appellate decisions including Grey v. LIC Development Owner and Choi v. Linc LIC, which supported tenant claims involving certain post-2019 concessions.

According to litigation data compiled by Adler & Stachenfeld, at least 21 lawsuits involved more than 24 properties, approximately 12,000 apartments and $1 billion in 421-a tax benefits.

Major landlords facing claims included Two Trees, Black Spruce Management and Blackstone, alongside other New York residential operators.

What the Updated Fact Sheet 40 Means for Landlords

DHCR's revised guidance explicitly states that the agency continues to recognize distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents. It also clarifies that the 2019 revision was not intended to eliminate that distinction.

That gives property owners a stronger basis to argue that temporary rent relief should not automatically become a permanent preferential rent.

The updated guidance points toward a case-by-case review. Relevant factors can include the circumstances that prompted the concession, physical conditions affecting the property, occupancy conditions, the length of the rent reduction and the language used in the lease agreement.

For landlords, this is particularly important for concessions offered during the pandemic, periods of weak occupancy or construction-related disruptions.

What the Change Means for Existing Rent Overcharge Litigation

The revision could weaken lawsuits built primarily on the argument that every post-2019 rent concession automatically qualifies as a preferential rent.

Landlord attorneys have described the change as a significant development that improves their ability to challenge claims. Bisnow also reported that attorneys expect the updated guidance to make some lawsuits more difficult to pursue.

However, the clarification does not erase the appellate decisions or guarantee that pending cases will be dismissed. Courts must still determine whether individual concessions were genuine temporary agreements or effectively reduced the monthly rent.

The distinction between a legitimate concession and a preferential rent will remain central to the litigation.

What NYC Multifamily Owners Should Watch Next

The next major development will be how New York courts interpret DHCR's revised guidance in pending and future cases.

For landlords, the update reinforces the importance of documenting why concessions were offered, how long they lasted and exactly how they were structured in lease agreements.

For owners of rent-stabilized buildings, the clarification could reduce exposure to substantial rent-overcharge claims and provide greater flexibility when offering temporary incentives to attract and retain tenants.

The regulatory shift is meaningful, but the financial impact will depend on court decisions and the facts behind each property's lease history. 

#New York#Legal News#Multifamily#Residential
Published: Nov 18, 2026Last updated: November 18, 2026